San Mateo Restaurant Reviews

See what our customers say about Windy City Pizza & BBQ!

“My boyfriend and I come here about 2 times a month. Super friendly staff and they make us feel special every time. They almost already remember our order. The food is delicious! Our fav pizza spot in San Mateo!”
-Gemma E.
pit smoked bbq san mateo“Classic Chicago deep dish pizza. The pizzas are cooked to perfection. No burnt areas and the cheese is gooey delicious. The crust is flaky and not hard like other pizzas. They also have awesome Texas style bar b que. The ribs are smokey and tender. If you order ribs and a pizza, you have an awesome meal.”
-Spencer Price

best pizza san mateo

“Soooooo good!!!! We usually order the deep dish mushroom and spinach with red head (tomato sauce on top), we have never been disappointed! It’s super loaded with provolone cheese and mozzarella, tasty, juicy, soft crust and a pool of tomato sauce, pure heaven.
The dough has a very interesting sweet aftertaste, I really like it.
Normally, knowing that it takes 45 minutes, we order at the phone and then pick it up, never had any issues of any kind. For us its a staple when we crave comfort food!”
-Michelle C.

San Mateo pizza delivery

“Excellent deep dish pizza and a good variety of beers on tap to go along with the pizza.”
-Philip K .

“The food was awesome.  We had the BBQ and it certainly was some of the best I have tasted.  It could be a little more seasoned, but still very good.  We had the collard greens and Mac and cheese and it was tasty.  Peach cobbler was awesome.  Just a great little place.  Servers were also very personable.  I highly recommend it.  Ribs are a nice size and we are eaters so you probably could get away with a half of slab unless you want leftovers.”
-Melissa M .

“We came here specifically for two items: Chicago Dog and Italian Beef.  OMG!!!!!  I seriously wish this place was within walking distance.  Being born in Chicago and living in the Northwest burbs for half my life, I do know when these two sandwiches taste like I’m back in Chicago…and they did. Can’t wait to return for a Bears game. Too bad they don’t serve Old Style any longer.  We also ordered a deep dish pizza. It was quite good.  BTW, the staff is terrific too.”
-Suzie K.

David-D-San-Francisco-Yelp-Review

“The first time I came here we got a pizza and ribs. Both were the best I’ve ever had in my life… The BBQ was awesome perfectly smoked meat and I loved the sauce.”
-Jim S.

“It’s really hard to find Chicago style pizza here in the Bay Area…So far, the pizza has always been really awesome. It’s very true to the Chicago style and the flavors are delicious. The crust is my favorite part and it’s very, very tasty.”
-Priscilla S.

eunice-san-mateo-yelp-review

“Great bbq’d meats. Wonderful meal! I couldn’t ask for better service! Trish and the gang treated us like family. Trust me I travel for bbq and this one is a winner. Come to a place that “get’s it.” Good food and good people!”
-Alan N.

pizza delivery San Mateo

“Absolutely love this place. Great food, great people, great customer service. This place is full of Chicago Bear fans every Sunday! #beardown We used to come here every Sunday to watch football games but we moved away temporarily so we stopped coming. Today is the first time we’ve been back, and the owners welcomed us with hugs (like they do every time we come & to many customers). Point being…it can’t get any better than this.”
– (5 star Yelp review) Cristina M. San Jose, CA

san mateo pizza restaurants

“Still love this place 2+ yrs after my first review. I have also tried the thin and redhead style. Redhead (tomato sauce on top) is pretty darn tasty, and the thin is well done. Of course, the thick crust regular style still reigns. Always plenty of cheese on the pizza, which is a must. We have ordered takeout many times for social get togethers at our place, never been disappointed.”
– (5 star Yelp review) Philip L. Redwood City, CA

sebastian-5-star-yelp-review

“My husband and I are big deep dish pizza fans. After searching from Berkeley to San Francisco we think we have found the best “Chicago” style pizza at Windy City in San Mateo. It was even better than the Chicago Pizza we had in Chicago. Their sauce is great and there is a little cornmeal in the crust. They do not have the layer of tomatoes on top that you find at Zachary’s so it is not as acidic. The ingredients are plentiful and over the sauce and under the cheese. I hear the BBQ is great but we drive 45 minuets to get there so we always get the pizza. We order extra large and freeze the extra.”
– (5/5 review on TripAdvisor) RoxyTravel San Francisco, CA

BBQ-pizza-TripAdvisor-review

More Pizza & BBQ Yelp Reviews from Yelp

Leave your Windy City restaurant review on our Google Map/Places page, Yelp, or Google+ Pizza & BBQ page